Piano vs Button Accordion, which one should I choose?




Button accordions

Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties. It supports the website. So, thank you!

If you are debating which accordion to get, familiarizing yourself with the main types of button and piano accordions will be helpful. In this article, we want to point out the key differences between the two styles of the instrument.

Most beginners, unless they live in Russia, Serbia, or Latin America will pick up a piano accordion as their first musical instrument. Most accordions sold in the United States, Canada, and United Kingdom are Piano accordions. Most accordion experts believe that this is due to the influence of Italian migrants who popularized this instrument in North America.

Chromatic Button accordions have the treble (right hand) side buttons arranged in chromatic order. Any set of three adjacent rows of notes (buttons), will give the notes chromatically. This type of accordion is also unisonoric. (a pressed button will produce the same tone regardless of the direction of the bellow motion).

Which accordion is easier to play?

While most novices and even intermediate accordion students will stick to a piano accordion for several years, playing a chromatic button accordion (often abbreviated as CBA) is not as difficult as many believe.

Video courtesy of Roxy Music Store

Similarities between a Piano and a Chromatic Button Accordion

Most accordionists who switch to a chromatic button accordion find it easier to play at times. Keep in mind that there are two different kinds of Button accordions, Diatonic (aka Bisonoric) and Chromatic (Unisonoric) whereas there is only one kind of Piano accordion. Chromatic button accordions can play sharps and flats, and, in that sense, they are very similar to piano accordions.

Advantages of the Chromatic Button Accordion

  • They have a wider range of notes which enables accordionists to play more complex pieces. Chromatic accordions can have a maximum of 64 notes in the right hand and Piano accordions can have a maximum of 45 notes.
  • Chords can be played with uniformed fingering patterns.
  • CBAs (Chromatic Button Accordions) are equipped with duplicate rows of buttons which enables the accordionist to play both, chords, and melodies.
  • Reaching notes (buttons) is a lot easier on a CBA than it is reaching notes (keys) on a piano accordion.
  • Chromatic Button Accordions are often a lot more compact and often easier to transport and carry.

Some advantages of Piano Accordions

Accordion to many accordionists, piano accordions are easier to learn for beginners, especially if they had taken piano lessons in the past. Most beginners also find Piano accordions easier for playing by ear. If you live in the US, Canada, European Union, China, or the UK, buying a quality Piano Accordion is a very easy process. Also, tutors, teachers, schools, and instructional books, for piano accordions are easily accessible in those regions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest posts

  • The Growing Popularity of The Accordion in India

    The Growing Popularity of The Accordion in India

    Although not as widely used as the harmonium in India, the accordion has been steadily increasing in popularity. As a versatile free-reed instrument, the accordion can produce sounds similar to the harmonium and is being embraced by a growing number of young musicians across a variety of genres.

    Read more

  • The Ten Best Accordion Players In History

    The Ten Best Accordion Players In History

    Discover the Top 10 Accordionists of the Modern Era. This curated list highlights the legacy and significant contributions of the world’s greatest accordionists. Whether you’re a seasoned accordionist or simply an admirer of music, this article is a must-read. Expand your knowledge and admiration of accordion music by acquainting yourself with these virtuosos.

    Read more

  • Postural health and safety for Accordionists

    Postural health and safety for Accordionists

    To derive the fullest potential of your accordion-playing capabilities, it is vital to have a proper posture while handling this musical instrument. As an accordionist, you should learn how to lift and carry the device properly – as well as unmounting it without any harm done – so that its magical sound can be produced…

    Read more